Reviews

A Review Of The Sinking City

Plagued by nightmarish visions of a drowned town along with a colossal tentacled monster, personal detective Charles Reed travels into the waterlogged city of Oakmont to locate answers. And to make things worse, the bizarre locals are profoundly suspicious of outsiders. However, with the origin of, and possible remedy to, all these harrowing visions lurking somewhere in town, Reed does not have any option except to receive his feet wet.

Divers discover an ancient cavern concealed under Oakmont stuffed with figurines of demons that are cosmic, and therefore are driven mad with the discovery–a madness that starts to spread throughout town and awakens odd, violent monsters that the natives call wylebeasts. The game is split between solving crimes and shooting critters, even though the gulf in quality between every flavour of drama is really broad.

Therefore, The Sinking City is adequate detective sport –especially in its usage of this intentionally Sherlock-inspired Mind Palace system. As you research a crime scene you gather hints that, while useless in their own, may be linked from the Mind Palace to start new lines of analysis. And you need to make these links yourself, with no hand-holding or tips, which creates a successful deduction particularly gratifying.

However, while Sherlock Holmes must rely entirely on his intellect and instinct to solve a puzzle, Reed has a supernatural benefit. In certain places a luminous blue portal site will open up, through that he could observe whichever offense transpired there. These vignettes arrive in the shape of glistening silhouettes of those folks involved and fragments of language. Reed should then construct a story, figuring out the sequence these echoes of the past happened in, which will normally bring about a fresh clue appearing at the Mind Palace.

Second –the punchline which should round off any fantastic detective story. In leaving Holmes supporting, the programmer’s knack for composing a good mystery appears to have endured. Reed is also an entirely charmless protagonist, with not one of Holmes’ humor, quirks, or nuance. He is the worst form of grim, gravel-voiced personal dick stereotype and I truly struggled to adore him.

In terms of the over-the-shoulder gun battle, it is perfectly usable, but seems just like a box being ticked as opposed to a very important portion of the game. Bullets being Oakmont’s principal type of money (it is a very long story) adds an intriguing element of ammo conservation to every wylebeast experience. But mainly I was only excited for the shooting to stop so that I could restart being a detective. There is an easy crafting program in there also, permitting you to create health records, ammo, and other helpful things from crap gathered on earth. However, like the battle, this is rather rote. I believe as The Sinking City are a much better, more consistent match if it concentrated purely on the discovering aspect.

The Sinking City’s dull setting is also really hard to love. It is an open world match, allowing you freely explore the roads of Oakmont. And while I adore having to follow instructions and listen to road names to locate important places, this gloomy, muddy, perpetually rain-soaked town is a totally miserable space to exist . There is some wonderful world-building, such as districts which have been almost entirely submerged, with only the shirts of lamp articles poking from the muddy water. But overall the town feels disappointingly dead, with robotic NPCs drifting aimlessly, insistent scenery, and also a forgettable, droning soundtrack adding to the feeling of gloom.

There is a great, but not good, detective sport lurking here–one that does not quite stack up with the finest of Frogwares’ Sherlock series. However, as a bundle, it does not quite do the job. The open world is not interesting enough to induce you to research it; the battle is fundamental and uninspiring; along with the writing and building of the puzzles are usually rather poor. In the event that you were searching for a special or unexpected spin on Lovecraft’s unique brand of terror, you won’t find it . There are a number of moments of quality hands on detecting to enjoy at The Sinking City.

About Luke Weston

Gamer, Blogger and all round nerd. I run the Occasional Gamer site and blog as often as possible.
View all posts by Luke Weston →